WildFact
›
General Section
›
Debate and Discussion about Wild Animals
Overrated size of Munna aka Langda of Kanha National Park
Overrated size of Munna aka Langda of Kanha National Park
|
Overrated size of Munna aka Langda of Kanha National Park
|
oh boy, here we go again.. Goodluck Amnon242, you're going to need it.
Ya, says the voice of reason.
[img]images/smilies/dodgy.gif[/img] Lets see what this reasonable poster has said Copters writes "don't forget that both Pattewala male and Munna are larger than Langda." "Also not all central tigers are photographed, you must have seen camera trap pictures from Tadoba & Kanha on tigerluver's blog, how large these tigers are" you also quoted "munna as being the largest tiger in Kahna" Posted on this thread As well as stating that Waghdoh is "320kg+" just can't find the thread atm.  (08-21-2014, 09:47 PM)Pckts Wrote: Amnon- Ok, without numerical data this discussion is useless :)
For what?
Numerical Data is one form of Data. All Data is excepted and used. Wether you wan't to use it or not is completely up to you, but still Data none the less. 
While I agree with Pckts on most of his views, I condemn the distorted views expressed by the supposedly resident expert here, Roflcopters.
Sorry Sanjay, I'm leaving this forum for good. All the best on your wildphoto venture where I'll continue to contribute as long as you keep that forum inviolate from such troubled souls.[img]images/smilies/dodgy.gif[/img] 
@Vijay Rajan , I can understand your concerns, But this is forum, And a debate is expected. My and Moderators fault is that we have to stop this debate to go at this level.
My request to you is that you can create your own topic here and keep posting your information without interfering others. The photography section is not a forum, its website. And I can make you believe that, It is full of with lot of sincere people, most of them are wildlife photographer. So that place must be first place for you. Last thing, If you want to write blog/article You can use http://wildfact.com instead. I hope you will understand my problem and being my good friend will be with me. I full support you.
It's understandable Sanjay, this thread was pretty much spitting in the face of people who had actually seen these animals.
@Vijay I really hope you continue to enlighten on Ranth Tigers in the Tiger directory thread if you can. Your contributions have been greatly appreciated. (10-04-2014, 10:35 AM)'Vijay Rajan' Wrote: While I agree with Pckts on most of his views, I condemn the distorted views expressed by the supposedly resident expert here, Roflcopters.
There is no offense by Vijay to asking you for joining in FB ? At first he was impressed by your knowledge of tiger, but the way you debate not only make him angry but also raise the eyebrows of US.
Can you also post your reply to him ? I know Vijay better than you, He has real interaction with big cats. Why You Said, "Photographers don't know nothing". Rofl, I always backed you earlier, But now this is too much. I don't say anything about your posting regarding munna, But insulting Wildlife Photographer is offense, And this is my last request to you please don't do this to reputed members like Vijay.
I don't recall insulting him, can you show me where i insulted him? He took a jab at me so i just showed how two faced he was being here and going as far as calling me an *expert*. laughable, should i just let everything slide because he's a wildlife photographer and what does real life interaction mean in the scientific field? so if a guy sees a Tiger in the wild, does that give him more authority on tigers? more knowledge on their anatomy? I am sorry but i said nothing that should've offended him or anyone in the first place, this whole topic was made to have a discussion with Pckts and we did just that. even when we were done with this topic, me and Pckts got a long just fine and that's how you deal with things professionally imho. there are disagreement and agreements everywhere.
I am done replying on this topic, I didn't even know this was still going until i saw it on the news feed. [img]images/smilies/tongue.gif[/img] (10-07-2014, 06:57 PM)Roflcopters Wrote: I don't recall insulting him, can you show me where i insulted him? He took a jab at me so i just showed how two faced he was being here and going as far as calling me an *expert*. laughable, should i just let everything slide because he's a wildlife photographer and what does real life interaction mean in the scientific field? so if a guy sees a Tiger in the wild, does that give him more authority on tigers? more knowledge on their anatomy? I am sorry but i said nothing that should've offended him or anyone in the first place, this whole topic was made to have a discussion with Pckts and we did just that. even when we were done with this topic, me and Pckts got a long just fine and that's how you deal with things professionally imho. there are disagreement and agreements everywhere.You insulted Photographer and other person whom pckts presented as his backup. You didn't said anything directly to Vijay, But you insulted photographers and He is big name in Indian wildlife photographer community. You didn't showed your reply to him ? By looking your previous wonderful information he considered you as expert but when he saw you have no respect for other in your words, he got hurt. We are not saying you believe on anyone claim, either photographer, expert or anyone. Point is you should not insult anyone claims like you did in this thread. Your language used for other who don't agree with you is offensive. I am putting last word here and this topic is closed. |
| Users browsing this thread: |
| 1 Guest(s) |