Overrated size of Munna aka Langda of Kanha National Park

[Roflcopters]

(07-18-2014, 03:26 AM)'Pckts' Wrote:

(07-18-2014, 03:11 AM)'tigerluver' Wrote: I've no opinion on the debate, you guys are the modern tiger tracking experts. The only thing that bothers me about all these estimation from eye witnesses is the "much bigger" phrase. In pictures, all these cats look equally robust, so they're not referring to that. If they're referring to dimensions, no dominant male can be truly "much bigger" than another unless one can differentiate 8 inches (roughly 60 kg of weight difference) accurately from a distance on a moving target without the last tiger in front of him as reference. Just look at Khali, supposedly a giant tiger of modern times in this video. There's a clear size difference, but no dwarfing in dimension (obviously the weight is different story).

 

 

 


 

You can definitely see difference between robust tigers and not so robust tigers, IMO.
Waghdoh looks massive no matter what, in person or film. Patewala, Munna, Bamera, katezari, Jai etc..
Those tigers look huge,
tigers like
Raja and Shivaji look very muscular but not as bulky, then when you see the gaur hunt video or raja walking infront of the Jeep, you realize how massive they really are. Shivaji is said to be massive as well but looks to be a shorter stockier tiger, so it depends.

Thats why I like to take as many eye witness accounts as I can and compare to see if the facts line up.



Copters has far more expierence with Tigers than I do, and he knows way more about Indian tiger personalities, but I don't think he has seen any of the Kahna Tigers in person, correct Copters?
That is why I prefer to take these eye witness accounts and claims.
If you have seen them in person, I would quickly take your word on it.

 Also, Khali looks far larger in the video. Much more massive, taller and longer. Remember, you aren't talking about differences in feet, but rather inches. So you'll never see a complete mismatch, these tigers need certain size to even attempt to usurp a resident male from a territory. That being said, Waghdoh is always quoted as being untouchable outside of the Kaziranga monsters which I think the unanimous consensus is, they're the largest tigers alive today.

 

I know a plenty of people that have seen Munna out in action and no one really thought he was anything more than average, Sure big to some that have never seen Tigers like Wagdoh, Shivaji, Jay, Katezari, Pench's Charger, Raja, Agasthya, Ram, Bamera, B2 etc etc but overall, Munna's size was overrated by many, that is all. I don't want to keep running around the bushes here and Yes, I agree with the last statement. Outside of Nepal/Assam area, Wagdoh is the largest by far.





 

  Reply